Is the Khaite Scarlet Cardigan Worth It? A Fashion Editor's Personal Take After 3 Years of Wear

If there’s one cardigan that’s achieved iconic status in the fashion world, it’s the Khaite Scarlet Cardigan. You’ve likely seen it on Pinterest boards, street-style galleries, and even on A-list celebrities (Katie Holmes’ infamous bra-and-cardigan moment instantly comes to mind). At £1,800, it’s far from a casual purchase, but its reputation as an investment piece has kept it at the forefront of luxury knitwear for several seasons. After owning the Khaite Scarlet Cardigan for three years, I’m here to answer the question everyone’s asking: Is the Khaite Cardigan worth it?

First, let’s address the elephant in the room: the price tag. The Scarlet Cardigan is undoubtedly a splurge, but for good reason. Khaite has built its name on crafting timeless staples that marry quality materials with contemporary design. The Scarlet Cardigan embodies this ethos, offering a plush cashmere feel and a slouchy yet structured fit that’s impossible to replicate. Unlike many knitwear options that lean either too oversized or too fitted, this cardigan strikes the perfect balance, with a slightly cropped hemline and voluminous sleeves that drape effortlessly. It’s versatile enough to wear year-round—pair it with jeans in the winter or drape it over a slip dress in the summer.

What makes the Khaite Scarlet Cardigan even more remarkable is its staying power in the fashion scene and in my wardrobe. Chunky knitwear is hardly new, but season after season, designers from Chanel to Isabel Marant continue to spotlight luxe cardigans styled in innovative ways. This only underscores how the Scarlet Cardigan aligns with both timeless and trending aesthetics. Over the years, I’ve styled mine in countless ways: with jeans and loafers for casual outings, paired with loungewear for at-home elegance, and even dressed up with wide-leg trousers for an office-ready look. It truly lives up to its reputation as an investment piece, proving its cost-per-wear value time and again.

Another standout feature is its impressive array of colour options, which only adds to its versatility and appeal. Whether you gravitate toward timeless neutrals like black, ivory, or camel, or prefer a pop of seasonal hues like rich burgundy or deep forest green, there’s a shade to suit every wardrobe and personal style. This variety makes the cardigan a true investment piece, as it can seamlessly integrate into different aesthetics and occasions. Neutrals work effortlessly for everyday wear, while bolder colours offer a fresh, unexpected twist. Owning the Scarlet Cardigan in multiple shades (one can only wish!) could even transform it into a foundational element of your wardrobe, making outfit planning a breeze no matter the season or event.

That said, no cardigan is without its drawbacks. The Scarlet Cardigan is undeniably delicate, requiring mindful care to avoid pilling or stretching (a problem I’ve faced with less luxurious knits). While the cashmere quality is excellent, its lightness means it’s better suited for transitional seasons than the dead of winter unless layered strategically. And, of course, its high price point makes it unattainable for many. But if you’re someone who gravitates towards timeless, well-made staples—and is prepared to commit to their care—it’s hard to argue against the Scarlet Cardigan’s merits.

So do I think the Khaite Scarlet Cardigan is worth it? After three years of wearing it, I can confidently say it lives up to the hype. Its impeccable craftsmanship, versatile design, and array of colour options make it a standout investment piece that transcends trends and seasons. While the price tag is undeniably steep, the quality, durability, and cost-per-wear value make it a worthwhile addition to any wardrobe for those who prioritise timeless style and thoughtful purchases. Whether you’re drawn to its classic neutrals or want to make a statement with bolder hues, the Scarlet Cardigan is a piece that can effortlessly elevate your wardrobe, no matter how you choose to style it.